Similar Recipes
Key Lime Pie
Use fresh citrus for a Key lime pie with bright, tangy flavor.
Key Lime Tart
Key lime pie is definitely an icon of Key West, Florida and a delicious dessert and even better as key lime tart. Using meringue instead of whipped cream is also a popular choice.
Key Lime Pie Cake
This cake is a riff on Key Lime Pie, complete with a tart key lime curd icing and buttery graham cracker crumbs.
Perfect Key Lime Pie inspired by Dexter — Binging With Babish
In a fan-favorite episode, Dexter Morgan takes a break from his close-up, slow-motion morning routine to kill a friend in need. But he can't saran-wrap her to a table and scalpel her cheek like any other Monday, he's gotta be nice about it, so he finds the best key lime pie in Miami and pumps it ful
Fresh and Creamy Lime Pie
This pie relies on the killer combo of citrus and dairy (think Creamsicle) for a mellow, sweet, and sour dessert.
Vegan Key Lime Pie
A lime custard pie that hits all the same flavor notes as a Key lime pie, but entirely vegan.
Pineapple Pie
This pineapple pie is a revelation, and one you won't typically see on a pie menu. Lime juice and zest give it an added zing.
No-Churn Lime Ice Cream Pie (No Ice Cream Maker Required)
Cool, clean, and pleasantly tart lime ice cream is just one step away from becoming a dead-ringer for key lime pie. Let's make it happen.
Lemon Meringue Pie
This lemon meringue pie has a tangy and bright lemon filling that's nestled in a flaky pie crust and topped with pillowy clouds of bruléed meringue.
Coconut Cream Pie
Filled with a rich custard and topped with lightly sweetened whipped cream and toasted flaked coconut, this coconut cream pie is fragrant, nutty, and a delight to eat.
This recipe is a combination of two. The filling is from chef and tv host Andrew Zimmern who got it from a Miami firefighter who got it from someone in the Keys. The crust is the spectacular creation from Christina Tosi of Momofuku Milk Bar. Together, they make a perfect key lime pie. Your support keeps the show running and is very much appreciated. If you'd like to leave a donation for this recipe, please click HERE. Thank you!
Serve With
Islas Flotantes de Coco (Coconut Floating Islands)
Though some recipes call for baking the meringues and then slipping them into the custard, I follow the more traditional route and poach them. A bite reveals that these islands are rather more like clouds.
Tropical Pineapple, Mango, and Coconut Fools
The classic British fool, a dessert of fruit and whipped cream, is an ideal warm weather dessert because it's light and balance of sweet and tart fruit flavors. Spooned into this tropical take are layers of juicy mango, pineapple, and toasted coconut.
Strawberry Cheesecake Sundae Pots
Like the look of this? It's incredibly easy to make - and no bake! A twist on the classic cheesecake, this is perfect for entertaining because all the elements can be made ahead then simply assembled prior
Fruity No-Churn Ice Cream
This ice cream relies on the power of a stand mixer, rather than a proper ice cream machine, and can be made with any sort of freeze-dried fruit.
Strawberry Dream Pie Ice Cream
The goat cheese base for this ice cream is flexible enough for a range of fruits and other flavors. Want to use blueberries instead? This base is lemony enough for them. Prefer brownie chunks with a swirl of dulce de leche? Goat cheese is savory enough to counteract the sweetness. But it's pretty awesome with strawberries, as used here.
Dulce de Leche Ice Cream with Samoas
Dulce de leche ice cream studded with nubs of coconutty Samoa cookies.
Guilt-free Frozen Mango Coconut Ices
These frozen mango coconut ices are a cooling, delicious guilt-free dessert––perfect for the last days of summer, outdoor barbecues and sitting by the pool.
Coconut-Palm Sugar Ice Cream
Palm sugar lends a soft caramel flavor with a tinge of butterscotch that makes this ice cream special. Add coconut milk, eggs, and pandan to the team and we've got a combination of flavors that South East Asians have enjoyed for ages.
Scooped: White Chocolate Mint Ice Cream with Pomegranate Molasses
White chocolate, of course, isn't chocolate. It's comparisons to the dark stuff that so frequently disappoint tasters. So let's step past the unfortunate comparisons and consider white chocolate on its own terms. Once you get by the whole chocolate malapropism, white chocolate's flavor is pretty awesome: a buttery vanilla with strong hints of mint and other leafy herbs.
Coffee 'N Cookies 'N Cream Ice Cream
This recipe blends fragrant, creamy Tahitian vanilla bean with ground coffee for a sweet, rich, coffee-tinged base for crushed Oreos.